Photo Books

sun_borealis.jpgSince I was catching up on my digital photography skills recently (summer '07), I thought I'd keep track of the photo-related books I looked at (or read), just for the record.

It turns out that especially in this area there is a whole lot that gets published (it must sell really well), but very little that is actually useful or good. Most books just load up on very pretty poictures (taken with very expensive equipment, noot the PS cameras they  explain), and the good ones (i.e., with substantive, useful information or advice) are much harder to come by than you may think! I feel even more grateful than before for northern Wisconsin's surprisingly  well-stocked public library system...

Here, all the books are listed here from highest, to lowest-ranked; reviews included here were also posted to amazon.com (US) for each title, respectively.

  • The Q&A Guide to Photo Techniques
    by Lee Frost

    MY RATING: ***** (5 out of 5 stars)

    The book addresses most common questions beginning or intermediate photographers may have; it provides numerous well chosen examples. Most photos were taken by the author and include (surprisingly, a very unusual but useful feature among photo books) relevant shooting info. to illustrate the pint (e.g., what camera or film or lens was used; in some cases what filers or exposure values were used as well). It has some of the most useful diagrams I have ever seen in photo instruction books (e.g., a comparative diagrapm / infographic on different focal lengths and viewing angle for each type of lens, with actual images shot at each specific zoom length); there are also brief but useful and very USABLE = specific sections on techniques (e.g., Night exposure guide on p. 119 should be reprinted and sold as a plastic pocket reference card on its own - it's THAT good). In a year or twoo it will need an update to include more digital-related material, but even as it is, this book is a real gem in a vast see of pretty but often unhelpful titles on the topic. A must read. I fully intend to get my hands on all other books by Lee Frost.

     
  • The Photographer's Eye: Composition and Design for Better Digital Photos
    by Michael Freeman

    MY RATING: ***** (5 out of 5 stars)

     An excellent, informative book on one, single (but nonetheless important, topic: photo image composition.  So good, in fact, it deserved its own separate review on my blog. Highly recommended.

     

     
  • National Geographic: The Ultimate Field Guide to Photography
    by Bob Martin, Richard Olsenius, Robert Clark, John Healey, Debbie Grossman

    MY RATING: **** (4.5 out of 5 stars)

    This is a solid, basic, but fairly detailed and up-to-date intro to various aspects of photography, that includes sensible introductions written by expert photographers, and covers a range of topics from obvious (exposure) to more exotic (using phone cameras for diaries and travelogues or putting edible versions of your pictures on a birthday cake); it includes brief 2-page interviews with luminaries that explain a particular photo or similar 2-page " portfolio" spreads that showcase their work. I wish it had more info about each of the numerous photos included, especially regarding camera, exposure info and lens info (a few examples have it, most don't). There is an intro section on photo-editing in Photoshop, a section on scanning, and a very brief but competent history of film photography every aspiring amateur should know. This is not an in-depth book on a particular type of photography (such as sports or macro or travel) or technique (such as exposure or nigt-photography), but it is a good point of departure for beginners, and a good orientation in existing techniques and possibilities. Highly recommended.

     
  • The Photographic Guide to Exposure
    by Chris Weston

    MY RATING: **** (4 out of 5 stars)

    Weston's book is a timeless classic. Sure, it's focus is largely on film photography, and it requires slow, careful, focused, and attentive reading, but the baisc concept of exposure is explained here better than in any other popular book on the subject I've read. From descriptions of different metering systems found in today's cameras, and different ways of approaching a scene which is a subject of a photograph, to incidental light metering, and a brief, but sensible introduction to the zone system, this is an outstanding book which picks up where Peterson's much less inquisitive, and by far more basic Understanding Exposure left its readers.

     
  • Total Digital Photography
    by Chris George

    MY RATING: *** (2.5 out of 5 stars)

    Read my review here 

     
  • Low Budget Shooting: Do It Yourself Solutions to Professional Photo Gear
    by Cyrill Harnischmacher

    MY RATING: *** (2.5 out of 5 stars)

    This book is a GREAT idea: to show amateur photographers how to build lighting and studio-like equipment using materials and supplies available at the hardware or hobby store (e.g. kite building store for carbon fiber tube connectors).

    While I applaud the IDEA, the execution is fairly THIN; after flipping through the book at the bookstore you will quickly realize that it's 90% good looks, and only 10% useful content. Yes, the 10% can easily be described as VERY USEFUL content, but what's in here would easily fit in a 3-page article in Popular Photography or Digital Camera.

    Further, it looks to me, like the supplies used in the examples were those available in Europe, so there is no USA-specific advice on where to get that stuff, and no mention of possible brand names that might make online search much easier. In fact, the publisher chose to leave the last SEVERAL pages completely blank! They may have been used more wisely for a list / appendix of US stores or online places that sell some of the stuff shown here, as well as brand names under which some of the materials may be sold in the US. Hopefully, for the next edition, the publisher will take some time + effort to adapt this better to US needs. If would be nice it the book were 50% good looks and 50% substance. 

     
  • Digital Photography Expert: Close-Up Photography: The Definitive Guide for Serious Digital Photographers (A Lark Photography Book)
    by Michael Freeman
    MY RATING: ** (2 out of 5 stars)

    As another reviewer who gave it 2 stars, I agree that this is more of an "overview of the field" than a practical "how-to" book. For example, I picked up this book to find info about choosing the best macro lens(es) for flower close-ups, and to learn about the differences among most popular options (50 mm vs. 100 mm. macro properties); instead, the author goes into detail about using elaborate setups with lens extension rings (p. 14-15) and even provides a table with extension types and magnification each provides, but does not discuss the basic macro lenses available on the market to advanced amateurs and professionals alike...

    The diagrams that explain different lighting setups are helpful, but much of the book deals with setups and types of photography that will only interest specialized professional studio photographers (e.g. sections on museum reproduction and cataloging photos of coins, shells, gemstones and pearls, and reproduction of manuscripts / prints and paintings). Even in those cases, it seems that this is way too complex for an amateur, and yet not specific / detailed enough to be of use to an experienced (or aspiring) specialist. I was hoping this would be the same level of detail and quality as the same authors excellent book on black and white photos (in the same series), but it's not even close. It is certainly worth a look, if you can find it at the local library, burt not something I would recommend buying.

     
  • The Adobe Photoshop Lightroom Book: The Complete Guide for Photographers
    by Martin Evening

    MY RATING: * (1.5 out of 5 stars)

    This is a sensible book; not very well-written (as far as clarity of explanations), but OK. However, it applies to the initial ver. 1.0 release of LR, and is now largely obsolete.

    One has to command the author for providing a downloadable, 170-page, printable PDF-file update on the publisher's website (for free), however, the question remains whether you REALLY want to have to use this book alongside a hefty, plain paper printout from your home or office printer? As it is, it looks like at this time "Lightroom Adventure" is the only (or at least one of very few as of writing of this review) book that actually includes information for the current ver. 1.1.

     
  • Digital Photographer's Guide to Adobe Photoshop Lightroom (A Lark Photography Book)
    by John Beardsworth

    MY RATING: * (1 out of 5 stars)

    This was a very basic, barely OK book to start with. Based on the screen captures used to illustrate many points, much of it was being written based not even on the released version 1.0, but on an earlier beta (see sliders on the adjustment panels, and light-gray panels: all these were gone even in version 1.0).

    And now that Adobe released version 1.1 of LR, this really is to far from what the current software looks like (and how it works) to be of much use. For those looking for a current book that covers Lightroom 1.1, Photoshop Lightroom Adventure: Mastering Adobe's next-generation tool for digital photographers may be it. I haven't seen it, but I read online excerpts, and it does cover ver. 1.1.

     
  • Making Money from Photography in Every Conceivable Way
    by Steve Bavister

    MY RATING: * (1 out of 5 stars)
    (amazon does not allow 0 stars - in this case, it should)

    The book includes lots of information you already know if you approach things with a modicum of common sense. E.g., this fragment is characteristic of the book: (p. 48) "Having drawn up a shortlist of (image) libraries you feel should be suitable for your work, the next stage is to find out exactly what they require." Duh! Similar "gems" abound: "once you have been accepted [...] you will be expected to sign a contract" (no example of a sample or typical contract is included). The chapter on stock image libraries does NOT even include a brief list of image libraries you may consider (n fact, not even one is listed!), or a single spec sheet from an actual existing image library to give you an idea of what each requires (in terms of size or file format), and there is no index or appendix of places to consider. Same for other chapters.

    Embarrassingly, the issue 57 of this year's (2007) Digital Camera magazine in its cover section titled "Make cash with your camera" (authored by the  very articulate, no-nonsense freelancer and book author Lee Frost) provides more useful info on just a few pages than this entire book ( e.g., the article on stock libraries includes a list of stock agencies that accept submissions from amateur freelancers, with requirements of size and image type, as well as website addresses, etc. for each).

    To make things worse, the author cannot decide if the book is to be on how to sell what you have, or how to generate it in the first place ( e.g., a very general chapter on what lenses to use for wedding photography and similar sections on beginning technique are out of place here).

    My recommendation: save yourself the time and trouble. Get the back issue of Digital Camera, and you'll learn more.